The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is renowned for its moral complexity, and the secondary quest Following the Thread stands as a prime example of Geralt's world operating in shades of grey. Initiated via a notice board contract in Novigrad, this quest quickly shifts from a standard monster hunt into a personal tale of revenge involving fellow witcher Lambert. Navigating this storyline requires careful travel across multiple regions and presents players with key ethical decisions that alter narrative outcomes.
Starting the Investigation and Partnering with Lambert
The quest begins when Geralt accepts a contract to slay an ekimmara threatening the outskirts of Novigrad. Upon arriving at the monster's lair, Geralt discovers that Lambert is already engaged in battle with the beast. After defeating the creature together, Lambert reveals that his true objective was not the contract itself, but tracking down a murderer named Karadin.
Following a confrontation with the contract provider, the duo learns that Karadin operates within a larger syndicate involved in illegal slave trading. Keeping up with daily gaming news often reminds players how detailed CD Projekt Red's quest design remains years after release. Geralt and Lambert agree to split up to gather clues from different leads before rendezvousing for the final confrontation.
Tracking Leads Across Skellige and Novigrad
Geralt's portion of the investigation takes him to both Skellige and the bustling docks of Novigrad to interview key figures connected to Karadin. In Skellige, Geralt locates Hammond on the island of Faroe, where a tension-filled encounter inevitable turns into a combat scenario. Returning to Novigrad with new evidence allows the two witchers to pinpoint Karadin's exact residence.
During these preliminary stages, combat tactics play a significant role as Geralt faces groups of pirates and armed mercenaries. Proper preparation with Quen signs and fast steel sword strikes ensures smooth progression through these mandatory fights. Once all regional tasks are complete, Lambert waits outside Karadin’s gated estate, setting the stage for the narrative climax.
The Fate of Karadin: Key Choices and Ethical Impact
Upon confronting Karadin, players discover that the former witcher has seemingly reformed, living as a wealthy merchant with a family and funding charitable causes. Karadin claims to have left his violent past behind, putting Geralt in a position to either support Lambert's desire for vengeance or urge restraint. Choosing to spare Karadin forces Lambert to stand down, leaving the merchant unharmed while resolving the quest peacefully.
Conversely, siding with Lambert triggers an immediate boss fight against Karadin and his bodyguard companions. Defeating Karadin allows Lambert to satisfy his long-standing vendetta, though it leaves the estate in tragedy. Neither choice alters Geralt's core relationship with Lambert significantly, ensuring players can decide based purely on their own moral judgment.
Quest Rewards and Important Timing Considerations
Completing Following the Thread grants substantial experience points alongside loot gathered from fallen enemies throughout the questline. If Karadin is killed, Geralt can loot his body for valuable crafting materials, rare equipment, and a unique witcher diagram. Sparing him yields the same overall experience rewards without the additional loot from Karadin himself.
It is vital for players to complete this quest before advancing too far into the main storyline, specifically before starting the Ugly Baby quest. Failing to finish it prior to key story milestones can cause the quest to automatically fail, locking out Lambert's personal backstory. Planning this quest early ensures you gain all experience benefits while fully experiencing one of Novigrad's finest side stories.